|
Forum - General Questions |
|
Question
|
Doctor Who dissapointments
After seeing a great performance on the BBC of this music for big orchestra and choir, and after reading praise after praise on these soundtracks on the internet, i bought volume 3 and 4. What a BIG dissapointment! This is not real filmmusic, no real mature stuff. It's chaotic and has no 'feeling' of epic scoring as it should be. Is there anyone out there in the filmmusic-universe who agrees with me???
Blessings,
dirk.j.jansen, January 29, 2009; 6:35 AM
|
Answers
|
I bought the first two of Murray Gold's Dr Who CD's and was initially impressed with the first
CD (Season 1 and 2 I believe), the track 'Doomsday' being the highlight of the CD (also
somewhat altered performed in the proms concert). He improved and updated (pimped) the
classic Ron Grainger theme. However I quickly became bored with the repetitive action
tracks. It's all so massive and it eventually gives you a headache. I think it's great for the
series, but as a listening experience on CD not interesting enough. I hardly ever played the
second CD (season/series 3) so I passed on the series 4 CD. I also have 'Vanity Fair' by Gold,
and that too is a big disappointment for me. I have many scores for British costume dramas,
BBC and other productions, but this is one of the least interesting. It's all brass. That's what
he was asked to do, but I don't think I played the whole CD through even once. I think these
are effective scores for the TV programs, but not much beyond that. At least to me.
chris, January 29, 2009; 9:45 AM

Did any of you two try Ben Foster/Murray Gold's TORCHWOOD? I haven't listened to any Doctor Who soundtracks yet, but I really liked this CD which is said to be a kind of a spin-off from Doctor Who. I found it really melodic, although you two might wish for a more purely "unplugged" orchestra ;-)
handstand, January 29, 2009; 6:43 PM

|
Contribute an answer
|
|
|